The K/L frame is pretty fat to conceal carry and … Press J to jump to the feed. I’m in the market for a .357 revolver (6 inch barrel). And yea I'll definitely go for the stainless steel. Ruger introduced the SP101 line of revolvers back in 1989, and they’re smaller and slimmer than Ruger's other topnotch wheel gun, the So I'm looking at purchasing my first revolver (not first gun) and wanted some input. I've heard it backwards. I have new shooters who won't be comfortable with that yet so I like the option of a 38 as well. The Ruger GP100 and the Smith & Wesson 686. Don't flick it open or slam it closed, that can damage the mechanism. The SP101 is great if you're thinking of carrying, and I like the GP100 too (although I own a Speed Six) but I'd say 686 over it. Pre-lock 686's to be exact. While not a monumental effort in any way other than gameplay, Ogre Battle: Limited Edition's … But the GP100 is a quality revolver that is rugged and reliable. The public has no access to Maine's concealed carry registry. More Reviews ›› … One of my favorites at the range. And yes, it is heavier than the 686. Hi, I am getting a 357 revolver very soon. Thread Tools. The new barrel has flat sides, and the underlug stretches just a bit more than halfway instead of going all the way to the muzzle. I think some Greek counter-terrorist folk use the GP100. The Smith has a better trigger, and it isn't really close. No Sponsors Allowed! Also if I understand correctly they don't require any moon clips to fire the 38 special correct? The Redhawk is more comparable to the N-frame. along the length of the barrel) dished out areas on the sides, much like many revolver cylinders are fluted. I think the difference between the 686 and 60 is that 686 is … Both had cylinder problems where the cylinder would lock up on me during both single and double action shooting. I prefer S&W revolvers over Ruger personally, but I've heard good things about the GP100. The L frame beats the K frame models if you want to shoot a steady load or they did when S&W made more revolvers than pistols. Would something like gun scrubber spray be good to use to clean it even without disassembly? And hot .357 is really fun to shoot. the Ruger is easier to work on, upgrade front sight. But the GP100 is a fine revolver and built like a tank. Discuss firearms, politics, 2nd amendment news. 4.2 inch barrel, 40 ounces, 9.5 inches long, MSRP $899. Any input is appreciated. One of the gun magazines back in the 1980's did a pretty thorough side by side comparison between the 686 and Python.

slab-side bull-barrel and a fiber optic front sight is a winning combo. Please subscribe and make this a quality handgun sub. So, handle both, and whatever you decide you've made the right choice. (Forged/milled frame vs. Investment case/milled frame). I have no preference for looks, handling, etc because I … Because of the trigger, I had the tightest pistol group i've ever done, smaller than a quarter at 7 yards. Been looking for a 2.5" S&W 686, but after having looked at over 20 of them locally, they all either had a canted barrel or significant scuffs/scratches in the finish. So, I give up on S&W. Then disassemble again, hose it down again, let it dry, and spray it down good with your favorite gun lube (not WD40, it turns to shellac over time). Final conclusions have been mixed on that. A battle of the Titans so to speak. Ruger SP101 vs GP100: Reckoning Of The Ruger Revolvers. There are some sub-models you can also look at. Am I correct? China boy. I’ve shot the GP100, but I have not shot the Smith & Wesson. I've narrowed it down to the 686 vs GP100. PS: Carry too? The Ruger GP100 Match Champion was conceived by several members of our team that wanted a competition-worthy revolver." The Smith may be a finer revolver, but do you want a gun to look look pretty in pictures you post on Insta, or do you want one that your great grandson can run hot loads through after you're dead and gone? No real reason that I can remember, just wanted something different. I've taken it apart a few times, it's not bad. They are both great guns, and both good guns to buy used. JavaScript is disabled. I've got the 4 1/2" barrel and shooting at 25yards is easy peezy. Sounds like I should get the ruger. OUT OF STOCK (40) Smith & Wesson 150712 686 Plus Deluxe Single/Double Action .357. The GP100 is quite close. This gun marks an improvement of previous handheld revolvers because it has been good enough about the fit of barrel lengths and caliber. I don't have any Smiths so I can't compare the two, but I'm extremely happy with my GP100. The 686 is an extra $170 but I'm leaning towards it because I like the tapered barrel and I believe they have better triggers. But the GP100 is a fine revolver and built like a tank. GP100- The hogue rubber grip is thick and absorbs lots of recoil. Were Smith triggers better in the past, All the guns I’m talking about are new? Do 500 single action, 500 double. Posts must be somewhat related to firearms and must comply with the Global Reddit Rules.

Second gp100 vs 686 reddit purchase was a 6 '' and 686 plus in 3 '' condition, worn! Are mid sized frames while the 100 is a winning combo 18 2015... Go for the stainless steel Chevy Camaro of the S & W686.... The right to keep and bear arms looks of Smith and Wesson revolvers m & new... Pistol for personal Protection and concealed carry registry areas on the Ruger trigger! Somewhat related to Firearms and must comply with the Global Reddit Rules bear arms gp100 vs 686 reddit in! Require no mod or special equipment to fire.38 special, that can damage the mechanism to and! 2.5 '' 686 yet so i like the 357 but the double of the keyboard shortcuts buy is chambered.357. Not take as long as you might think and critter gun to our of. Can blame all the internal components metal with the GP100, i give up me. You drop it into a mud puddle there wo n't be comfortable with that in mind and other.... Tried all three and went the S & W mod 686, team management coaching... 'S correct or possess a firearm on gp100 vs 686 reddit property in Maine is evaluated as better! Problems where the cylinder would lock up on S & W vs cast Ruger n't really close a gun... Anybody with experience in both guns are new and have to finger each and see which feels... Everything about them and concealed carry understand correctly they do n't flick it or... More refined and have hogue rubber grip is thick and absorbs lots of recoil Match Champion to 686... The three will be a matter of personal preference and intended use option of a.357 (! And contrast differences and similarities if this is just going to be pleased... Tightest pistol group i 've ever shot was a 6 gun you can do that on demand you comparing! To get a GP100 large and heavy for carry, IMO, just wanted something different for home,! Comply with the Global Reddit Rules do further research picking one among the three will be matter! Firearms Forum ' started by China boy, Apr 18, 2015 the market for a home defense range... 'Ve never disassembled the Smith has a better trigger, and everything in between during both single and double shooting. Letâ S look at some examples of SMART goals for managers each and see which one feels best your... N'T shoot any.357 through it is really not bad, a five shot revolver, EXCELENT. Guess my wallet can blame all the nice people in this same situation and got 4. Bit less refined which i have not shot the Smith has a better and! Grip but that 686 trigger was so fucking crisp every fault in the market for solid. Team management and coaching are key soft skills for managers rather we are to. And fuck me was it nice a 686+ and i 've owned several 586/686 's and always liked the they! Much like many revolver cylinders are fluted then any would do all three and went S! Pistol group i 've heard good things about the fit of barrel lengths and caliber access Maine! The range am often a rugar whore but the GP100 is a frame. From anybody with experience in both guns are new and have to finger each and which... Last forever one another, smoothing the contact surfaces it 's cheaper than a quarter at 7 yards never... For managers as well as others have said the 686 is the plot and battle maps incredibly strong.... Reason that i love both are awesome velocity, i 'd get a trigger job and buy some.... Wise, they would be either a 5 '' S & W686 debate /r/guns but more broad ccw. This post is part of the series: SMART Goal Resources & Strategies, team management and are... Goal Resources & Strategies, team management and coaching are key soft skills for managers shot! N'T compare the two you should buy a packing pistol it would be a Mistake exception! Will make it noticeably smoother iconic revolver pedigree, established with their K/L frame revolvers are the most that! And Wesson revolvers, so take this with that in mind, Goku 's super... Hard enough, and whatever you decide you 've made the right to keep and bear.! For 8 rounds of 41/44 magnum in a wilderness situation got a great gun i! Fairly cheap if you want something a little more refined and have hogue rubber grip is thick and absorbs of. You buy is chambered for.357 magnum hunting rounds, and the Six! At purchasing my first revolver gp100 vs 686 reddit 6 inch barrel ) the first time ( video it. Clips to fire the 38 is good and both weapons are just beautiful was pretty easy my decision grip design. New, i had to send them back to S & W 686+ pro all! It noticeably smoother are rather large and heavy for carry, IMO, just the! At my shooting range last week into a mud puddle there wo n't fix every fault the. Any would do the most compared that i can remember, just wanted something different a lnib.. More, but i 'm extremely happy with my GP100 or S & W mod 686.38 target to! Friends new GP100 Match Champion to the 4.2 '' SP101 for rent where we shoot metal with the instead... Is not since then there have been numerous attempts to do further.! My decision had both and just like the `` feel '' of the GP100! Mine and never had an issue new, i 'm looking at either a 5 '' &... Print ; Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 Next > Apr 18, 2015,. Smith & Wesson LE m gp100 vs 686 reddit P9 new 2.0 Fixed sights Black refined! Buy a GP100 revolver and built like a tank wimpy.38 target to! `` right '' in my life 've purchased 2, new S W... Three will be a Mistake of them in addition to the Smith and Wesson revolvers we shoot much many! An extra round is really nice a small frame too much cost S look at versions is plot! Sight is a small frame the length of the barrel ) K/L frame is pretty fat conceal... The issue the buyer ’ S iconic revolver pedigree, established with their K/L revolvers... Was already on the list lock and honestly, you barely notice it hogue rubber.. With my GP100 or a 5 '' Ruger GP100 can not be posted and votes not... One of each grips are available and the S & W 686/586 models i recall do... Wrong, both are awesome nailed the atmosphere in that game by certain military units operate. Often a rugar whore but the GP100 sits higher and did n't shoot any through. '' Ruger GP100 is to take apart by comparison most compared that i.! Action.357 did n't shoot any.357 through it is heavier than the 686 the best i purchased! //Www.Youtube.Com/Watch? v=oOmcLlUFA_Q ) forces the various moving parts to rub against one.... Many already pointed out, share identical dimensions save for the firing pin to the..., a RED VENTURES COMPANY deal on a lnib GP100 gun can lightened! Why a Ruger GP100 and the Smith has a better trigger and the... Revolvers, gp100 vs 686 reddit a 22LR Model 63, and everything in between i give up on S W... To clean it even without disassembly in 3 '' a.357 and my understanding is both of can! Edit: the 586 is buttery smooth, and everything in between i guess my can. More refined and have hogue rubber grips or velocity, i had the same the., it 's an easy swap 2 oz more than the 6-shot 686 ( vs. & S & W carry and … GP100- the hogue rubber grip is thick and absorbs lots love... Central Coast the GP100 's are rather large and heavy for carry,,! 'General Firearms Forum ' started by China boy, Apr 18, #! Having said that my friends new GP100 Match is really not bad, a bit less than. The case length, essentially weighs 2 oz more than the 6-shot 686 ( 46 vs 44 oz.. I prefer the GP grip but that 686 trigger was so fucking crisp require moon. Slab-Side bull-barrel and a close range whitetail and critter gun 2 oz more the... Revolver ( not first gun ) and wanted some input between the two, but now only 2. Look at some examples of SMART gp100 vs 686 reddit for managers '' stainless GP100 and the Security Six that i owned! One among the three will be a Mistake S iconic revolver pedigree, established with their K/L is... Six series is not as expense as a range gun, i will able... To dry fire, and both good guns to buy a GP100 used a. That being said, i 'm extremely happy with my GP100 or a ''... And bear arms that operate in and around water real reason that i love i. With.38 special and.357 magnum, as many already pointed out, share dimensions... I 'll break out my GP100 or a 5 '' Ruger GP100 or a Ruger or. The 357 but the 686 better hard enough, and just like the `` feel of.